
A judge at the District Court of The Hague on 11 November ordered Jaguar Land Rover to have internal files seized from BYD’s Dutch offices destroyed, after finding JLR did not need them to argue that the BYD Ti 7 copies the Defender. The reason is the sentence that matters commercially: the car is not sold in the European Union, so there are no EU sales to calculate damages from. It goes on sale in Britain in January, at £47,995 — £23,845 less than a Defender 110 P300e plug-in hybrid. The ruling says nothing about whether the design was copied. It says the evidence gathering was not proportionate.
What the Court Actually Ordered
The case is C/09/713312 / KG ZA 26-1036, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33114, a preliminary relief matter decided by Judge H.F.R. van Heemstra. It concerns a seizure carried out in August at BYD’s offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp, granted to JLR on an ex parte basis — meaning BYD had no chance to contest it beforehand — and executed by a court bailiff.
| The order | Detail |
|---|---|
| Files held by | An independent court-appointed custodian; never handed to JLR |
| What JLR must do | Instruct the bailiff or custodian to destroy them within 24 hours of formal service |
| If it does not | €50,000 per hour, capped at €500,000 |
| Confirmation | JLR must give BYD independent proof of destruction |
| Further enforcement | Barred under the original authorisation; a breach carries a separate €500,000 |
| JLR’s own penalty claim | Rejected — the court found provisionally that BYD complied with the original order |
| Costs | BYD pays €25,376.57 |
| Status | Immediately enforceable, even if appealed |
Both companies declined to comment. The penalty structure is worth reading closely: at €50,000 an hour, the €500,000 cap is reached in ten hours, and the legal costs BYD was ordered to pay are about 5% of that cap — a reminder that in preliminary relief the deadline, not the damages, is the instrument.
Why the Court Took the Files Back
The reasoning is narrow and, for JLR, uncomfortable. The judge found that the seized material was not needed for two separate purposes.
First, to support the design claim itself. Second, to quantify damages — because the Ti 7, sold in China as the Fang Cheng Bao Tai 7, has not been launched in the EU. There is no European sales figure to multiply by a royalty rate, so there is nothing for internal R&D records to prove on that front. BYD’s lawyers had argued at the time of the raid that the seizure was a “fishing expedition” that swept up unrelated proprietary research.
What the ruling does is undo the seizure. It does not hold that the Ti 7 does or does not infringe, and it does not resolve the design question at all.
What This Is Not
Three things are worth separating from the headline.
It is not a win on the merits. JLR has separate proceedings running: a claim over the Defender’s EU design rights at The Hague, and copyright plus slavish-imitation claims at Rotterdam. Those are where the design question will actually be decided, and they are still live.
It is not a ruling that copying happened. The August raid followed JLR’s suspicion that BYD had bought a Defender to reverse-engineer it. Suspicion is what starts a seizure; it is not a finding.
It says something about which rights JLR has left. Under EU law an unregistered design gets three years from first disclosure; a registered Community design can be renewed in five-year terms to a maximum of 25 years. JLR has already failed to register three-dimensional shape marks for the Range Rover Evoque in the EU and for the classic Defender silhouette in the UK, which is why disputes of this kind end up argued on design rights and on “slavish imitation” rather than on trade dress. Its one clear precedent is the 2019 case against Jiangling over the Landwind X7.
The BYD Ti 7 Is £23,845 Cheaper
Here is why the paperwork fight is a sideshow.
| UK, from January 2027 | Figure |
|---|---|
| BYD Ti 7, Excellence AWD, seven seats | £47,995 |
| Land Rover Defender 110 P300e PHEV | £71,840 |
| Difference | −£23,845, or −33.2% |
| Powertrain | 1.5-litre turbo plus two motors, 300 kW / 402 hp |
| Battery and range | 35.6 kWh LFP Blade, 119 km WLTP electric |
| 0–100 km/h | 4.8 seconds |
| Showrooms / deliveries | November 2026 / January 2027 |
The energy figure is worth a second look: 35.6 kWh for 119 km of WLTP electric range works out at about 29.9 kWh per 100 km — a heavy, blunt shape with a lot of frontal area, exactly the trade-off a boxy off-roader makes. Our arithmetic from the two published numbers.
In China the Tai 7 has been on sale since September 2025 from 179,800 yuan as a plug-in hybrid, with a battery-electric version added in April 2026 from 199,800 yuan. Fang Cheng Bao’s general manager Xiong Tianbo put cumulative sales at 300,000 on 30 October, and Chinese reports put October volume alone above 20,000 — roughly one-fifteenth of the three-year total in a single month.
Britain Is Already Full of These Cars
The timing is what makes this more than a legal note. Chinese brands took 23% of UK new-car registrations in September, according to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, and in October the Jaecoo 7 — routinely described in the British press as a cut-price Range Rover — was the country’s best-selling model.
There is also an irony that JLR will not enjoy reading. The company has handed the Freelander name to its Chinese joint venture with Chery, and a right-hand-drive version is reported to be planned for the UK in 2027. JLR is simultaneously arguing that a Chinese manufacturer copied its most iconic shape, and licensing one of its own nameplates to a Chinese partner to build cars in the same market.
What Happens Next
The immediate sequence is procedural: service of the ruling, then 24 hours, then destruction, then confirmation to BYD. After that the case returns to the two merits proceedings, where JLR’s strongest tool is an injunction rather than damages — stopping UK sales would matter far more than a royalty calculation on a car that has not yet been sold in the EU.
That is the risk BYD is carrying into January. A single registered Community design found valid and infringed can support an application to restrain sales, and preliminary relief in Europe moves faster than a full trial. The Ti 7’s British launch price is a competitive weapon; it is also, if JLR wins on the merits, an argument for urgency.
Author’s Take: The interesting sentence in this ruling is not the destruction order; it is the court’s observation that there are no EU sales to calculate damages from. That is a statement about how early in the commercial cycle this fight is being fought — and it tells you the money is not in a royalty, it is in an injunction. JLR’s problem is no longer proving that the Ti 7 looks like a Defender; anybody can see that in a showroom. Its problem is that the design-rights toolkit it has left is thinner than the price gap it is trying to close, and that gap is 33%. A court can stop a car from being sold. It cannot make it cost £71,840.
The Bottom Line: A Hague court on 11 November ordered Jaguar Land Rover to have files seized from BYD’s Dutch offices destroyed within 24 hours, on pain of €50,000 an hour to a €500,000 cap, because JLR did not need them to argue its design case and there are no EU sales of the BYD Ti 7 to calculate damages from. The ruling does not decide infringement, and separate proceedings on EU design rights and slavish imitation continue. The Ti 7 reaches UK showrooms this month at £47,995, 33% below a Defender 110 P300e, with deliveries from January 2027.
Sources & Further Reading
- Nieuws.nl, citing Dutch news agency ANP — “Jaguar mag geen beslag leggen op BYD-documenten” (11 November 2026) — the ruling, the lifting of the August seizure, and the finding that the files were not required.
- Tencent News, citing China Energy News — “重大反转!荷兰法院驳回申请,比亚迪筑牢自研技术防线” (12 November 2026) — the procedural nature of the ruling, the finding that widespread surprise seizure lacked sufficient necessity, the absence of EU sales, BYD’s “fishing expedition” objection, and both companies declining to comment.
- District Court of The Hague, preliminary relief ruling of 11 November 2026 — Case No. C/09/713312 / KG ZA 26-1036, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33114, Judge H.F.R. van Heemstra: the destruction order, the 24-hour deadline, the €50,000/hour penalty capped at €500,000, the bar on further enforcement, the rejection of JLR’s penalty claim, and the €25,376.57 costs award. Reported by name and case number; EVsays has not read the judgment itself.
- Reporting on the August seizure — the ex parte authorisation, the Schiedam and Hoofddorp offices, the independent custodian, JLR’s reverse-engineering allegation, and the separate Hague and Rotterdam proceedings.
- BYD UK pricing and specification for the Ti 7 Excellence AWD — £47,995, showroom arrival November 2026, deliveries January 2027, 300 kW, 35.6 kWh, 119 km WLTP, 4.8 seconds. Land Rover UK list price for the Defender 110 P300e of £71,840, used for the comparison.
- Fang Cheng Bao Tai 7 Chinese pricing and volumes — PHEV from 179,800 yuan from September 2025, BEV from 199,800 yuan from April 2026, 300,000 cumulative units as of 30 October 2026, and October volume above 20,000.
- SMMT data on Chinese brands at 23% of UK registrations in September 2026, and October best-seller reporting for the Jaecoo 7.
- EVsays — the Fang Cheng Bao Tai 9 — the larger sibling in the same family, and where the brand is going next.
- EVsays — Fang Cheng Bao’s Formula S — the brand’s performance line, and how quickly it is widening its range.
- EVsays — BYD’s UK volume — the market the Ti 7 is being launched into, and how it compares with Tesla.
- EVsays — Chinese brands’ European market share — the trend behind the UK registration figures.
Notes: This ruling is a preliminary relief decision in summary proceedings; it lifts an evidence seizure and does not determine whether the BYD Ti 7 infringes any Jaguar Land Rover right, and we report it as such. The case number and judge are as reported; EVsays has not seen the judgment text, and the description of the court’s reasoning rests on Dutch and Chinese reporting of it, not on our reading of the document. Both companies declined to comment. The −33.2% price difference and the roughly 29.9 kWh per 100 km energy figure are our arithmetic from published prices and specifications, and the UK price comparison uses Land Rover’s own list price rather than a transaction price. Deliveries from January 2027 are BYD’s stated plan, not a completed delivery record. Follow our correction policy for amendments, and our editorial policy for sourcing standards.







